• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to footer
Medicare Plans

Medicare Plans

Open Medicare Plan Data.

  • Medicare Options
  • Costs
  • Answers
    • Eligibility
    • Options
    • Enrollment
    • Costs
    • Coverage
  • Medicare Advantage
  • Special Needs
  • Medicare Supplement
  • Prescription Drugs
  1. 🏠
  2. Medicare Advantage Plans
  3. Indiana
  4. Shelby County

2027 Medicare Advantage Plans in Shelby County, IN

Last update: November 7, 2026.

In Shelby County, IN, there are 38 Medicare Advantage plans available for 2027. Of these, 25 offer a $0 monthly premium, and about 39% are rated 4 stars or higher based on CMS quality ratings.

  • PPO Plans
  • HMO Plans
  • HMO-POS Plans

At a Glance

County-level summary of Medicare Advantage plan availability and enrollment based on CMS data.

Average Monthly Premium
$16.42/mo
Plans with $0 Premium
25
Average MOOP Limit
$6,928 ($9,250 max. in 2027)
Star Ratings (Plan Mix)
4+ Stars: 39% · 3 Stars: 55% · Below 3: 6%
Average Part D Deductible
$481.07
Total MA/MAPD Enrollment
1,202
Plans with the Highest Enrollment
(as of November 10, 2026)
1. Anthem Medicare Advantage (HMO-POS) — 533 enrollees
2. DEVOTED CHOICE 011 IN (PPO) — 113 enrollees
3. Aetna Medicare Signature (PPO) — 77 enrollees

Medicare Advantage Special Needs Plans (SNPs) are not included in the figures shown above. View Special Needs Plans in Shelby County, IN. Or explore all Medicare Options available in Shelby County, IN. To understand how local plans fit into the broader market, visit our Indiana Medicare Advantage plan directory for statewide plan counts, premiums, out-of-pocket limits, CMS ratings, and enrollment data.

Medicare Advantage PPO Plans

Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) plans allow access to both in-network and out-of-network providers. Out-of-network care usually costs more, but PPOs offer greater flexibility in choosing doctors and hospitals.

  • Total PPO Plans 28
  • Average Monthly Premium $17.11/mo
  • Total PPO Enrollment 609
  • $0 Premium PPO Plans 19
  • Average MOOP $7,190
  • Top PPO by Enrollment DEVOTED CHOICE 011 IN (PPO) — 113 enrollees
  • PPO Plans Without Drug Coverage 7

Comparison table of 2027 PPO Medicare Advantage Plans available in Shelby County, Indiana
Health Plan Name CMS Rating* Premium Per Mo MOOP PDP Ded. CMS Plan ID
Humana Essentials Plus Giveback
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $9,850 $700 H7617-144-1
Humana USAA Honor Giveback
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $7,900 N/A H7617-073-0
Aetna Medicare Eagle
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $5,200 N/A H5521-286-0
Aetna Medicare Signature
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $5,900 $500 H5521-231-0
Aetna Medicare Value Care
☆☆☆☆☆
$17 $5,200 $500 H5521-302-0
Humana Full Access
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $7,150 $700 H5216-192-0
Humana USAA Honor Giveback
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $7,900 N/A H5216-441-0
Humana USAA Honor Giveback
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $7,900 N/A H5216-218-0
Humana Value Choice
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $7,000 $700 H5216-229-0
HumanaChoice Giveback H5216-481
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $9,850 $700 H5216-481-1
HumanaChoice H5216-053
☆☆☆☆☆
$48 $6,800 $500 H5216-053-0
HumanaChoice H5216-463
☆☆☆☆☆
$43 $6,350 $500 H5216-463-0
Anthem Medicare Advantage
☆☆☆☆☆
$123 $9,250 $45 R5941-016-0
Anthem Medicare Advantage
☆☆☆☆☆
$45 $6,750 $95 H7093-002-0
Anthem Medicare Advantage 2
☆☆☆☆☆
$50 $6,750 $250 H1607-015-0
Anthem Medicare Advantage 3
☆☆☆☆☆
$68 $6,750 $150 H1607-012-0
Anthem Veteran
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $9,250 N/A H7093-001-0
HumanaChoice R0110-011
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $5,400 N/A R0110-011-0
HumanaChoice R0110-012
☆☆☆☆☆
$68 $9,850 $450 R0110-012-0
MyTruAdvantage Choice Complete
☆☆☆☆☆
$17 $4,460 $500 H9042-004-0
MyTruAdvantage Choice Plus
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $4,700 $500 H9042-007-0
Red, White and Tru
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $5,500 N/A H9042-008-0
Zing Open Choice IN
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $7,900 $450 H6876-004-0
Wellcare Giveback Open
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $9,850 $700 H6348-008-0
Wellcare Simple Open
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $6,200 $700 H6348-002-0
DEVOTED CHOICE 011 IN
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $4,550 $650 H7471-011-0
DEVOTED CHOICE GIVEBACK 012 IN
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $9,850 $461 H7471-012-0
DEVOTED CHOICE GIVEBACK EXTRAS 023 IN
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $7,300 $700 H7471-023-0
What is the total number of PPO plans offered in Shelby?

There are 28 PPO plans in 2027, covering 609 beneficiaries.

How much do PPO plans cost in Shelby?

The average PPO premium in Shelby is $17.11 per month, with 19 plans offering $0 premiums.

What is the most popular PPO plan in Shelby?

DEVOTED CHOICE 011 IN (PPO) is the top PPO in Shelby, with 113 enrollees.

What is the number of PPO plans without Part D coverage in Shelby?

There are 7 PPO plans in Shelby without prescription drug coverage.

Medicare Advantage HMO Plans

HMO plans typically require members to use in-network providers and facilities, except in emergencies. In return, HMOs often offer lower monthly premiums and reduced cost-sharing.

Total HMO Plans
2
Average Monthly Premium
$0.00/mo
Total HMO Enrollment
0
$0 Premium HMO Plans
2
Average MOOP
$4,925
Top HMO by Enrollment
— 0 enrollees
HMO Plans Without Drug Coverage
0

Comparison table of 2027 HMO Medicare Advantage Plans available in Shelby County, Indiana
Health Plan Name CMS Rating* Premium Per Mo MOOP PDP Ded. CMS Plan ID
MyTruAdvantage Select
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $3,900 $300 H6529-004-0
Zing Select Care IN
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $5,950 $450 H4624-003-0

What is the average monthly premium for HMO plans?

HMO plans in Shelby cost $0.00 per month on average.

Which HMO plan is most popular in Shelby?

The most popular HMO plan in Shelby is , with 0 enrollees.

How many HMO plans in Shelby do not include drug coverage?

There are 0 HMO plans in Shelby without prescription drug coverage.

Medicare Advantage HMO-POS Plans

HMO Point-of-Service (HMO-POS) plans combine HMO network rules with limited out-of-network access. Care outside the network typically costs more, but HMO-POS plans provide added flexibility compared with standard HMOs.

Total HMO-POS Plans
6
Average Monthly Premium
$18.67/mo
Total HMO-POS Enrollment
593
$0 Premium HMO-POS Plans
4
Average MOOP
$6,375
Top HMO-POS by Enrollment
Anthem Medicare Advantage (HMO-POS) — 533 enrollees
HMO-POS Plans Without Drug Coverage
0

Comparison table of 2027 HMO-POS Medicare Advantage Plans available in Shelby County, Indiana
Health Plan Name CMS Rating* Premium Per Mo MOOP PDP Ded. CMS Plan ID
Humana Gold Plus H5619-189
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $4,450 $600 H5619-189-1
Anthem Extra Help
☆☆☆☆☆
$17 $4,900 $700 H3447-024-0
Anthem Medicare Advantage
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $9,850 $150 H3447-042-3
Anthem Medicare Advantage 2
☆☆☆☆☆
$95 $6,000 $300 H7220-004-0
Anthem Medicare Advantage 4
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $7,150 $300 H7220-010-0
Wellcare Simple
☆☆☆☆☆
$0 $5,900 $700 H3499-002-0
What is the leading HMO-POS plan in Shelby?

Anthem Medicare Advantage (HMO-POS) is the top HMO-POS in Shelby, with 533 enrollees.

What is the number of HMO-POS plans without Part D coverage in Shelby?

0 HMO-POS plans in Shelby do not include prescription drug coverage.

The table below shows CMS star ratings for Medicare Advantage plans in Shelby County, IN for 2027.

CMS Star Ratings for Medicare Advantage Plans in Shelby County, IN (2027)
Rating Category Number of Plans Percent of Plans
5 Stars No 5-star plans available. 0%
4 Stars (includes 5 Stars) 13 39%
3 Stars 18 55%
Below 3 Stars 2 6%
Not Rated 3 8%
Average Rating 3.59

* Medicare Advantage star ratings are determined by CMS each year using a standardized 5-star rating system.

Medicare Advantage plans listed on this page are available to eligible beneficiaries residing in Shelby County, Indiana, including communities such as Fairland, Fountaintown, Morristown, Shelbyville, Waldron, and other areas throughout the county. Plan availability is determined by county of residence, not by city.

  • CMS.gov, Medicare Advantage & Special Needs Plan Landscape Source Files — Version: 202609
  • CMS.gov, Medicare Part C & D Performance Data — Version: 2026
  • CMS.gov, Medicare Advantage & Part D Contract and Enrollment Data — Version: 2026-10

County-level figures shown on this page, including plan counts, enrollment totals, averages, and percentage distributions, reflect standard Medicare Advantage (MA/MAPD) plans only and are derived from CMS datasets using a standardized aggregation methodology.

Data sources and methodology documentation .

  • Medicare.gov, "Compare types of Medicare Advantage Plans" — Last accessed 25 May, 2025
  • Medicare.gov, "Your coverage options" — Last accessed 25 May, 2025
  • Medicare.gov, "Joining a plan" — Last accessed 25 May, 2025

MedicarePlans.com is an independent, non-government informational resource and is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. Government or the federal Medicare program.

This page follows data provenance practices aligned with the USCDI Provenance standard .

Page content independently curated and maintained by David W. Bynon, Editorial Steward, using a standardized, data-driven methodology for accurate, non-commercial Medicare plan interpretation and resolution.

Footer

About This Site

  • About MedicarePlans.com
  • How We Use CMS Data
  • How We Make Money
  • Editorial Policy
  • Why We Exist

Policies & Standards

    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact Us
    • Terms of Use
    • Medicare Publishing Excellence Standards
    • Medicare Plans Research

Trademark Notice

MedicarePlans.com uses U.S. trademarks, service marks, and registered trademarks solely for purposes of identification, description, and factual reference. All such use constitutes nominative fair use and does not imply affiliation, endorsement, or sponsorship by any trademark holder.

© 2026 MedicarePlans.com. All Rights Reserved
MedicarePlans.com is an independent, non-commercial Medicare data platform.
Editorial stewardship: David W. Bynon